Comment on Mahariq et al. Investigation and Analysis of Acoustojets by Spectral Element Method. Mathematics 2022, 10, 3145; Mathematics; Vol. 10, iss. 23

Détails bibliographiques
Parent link:Mathematics
Vol. 10, iss. 23.— 2022.— [4502, 4 p.]
Auteur principal: Minin I. V. Igor Vladilenovich
Collectivité auteur: Национальный исследовательский Томский политехнический университет Инженерная школа неразрушающего контроля и безопасности Отделение электронной инженерии
Autres auteurs: Minin O. V. Oleg Vladilenovich
Résumé:Title screen
The paper under discussion has some shortcomings in regard to mathematical formulationof the problem related to acoustics, its justification, some references analyses and the text, and we feelthat this study has not been finished to its full extent. From the point of view of acoustic jet formation,the mathematical model used by the authors has a number of significant limitations which are nottaken into account. Moreover, the formal analogy between the parameters of electromagnetic wavesand acoustic waves should be used with caution in the conditions of localized beams (acoustic jet),and the limits of their application should be justified.
Langue:anglais
Publié: 2022
Sujets:
Accès en ligne:https://doi.org/10.3390/math10234502
Format: Électronique Chapitre de livre
KOHA link:https://koha.lib.tpu.ru/cgi-bin/koha/opac-detail.pl?biblionumber=668565
Description
Résumé:Title screen
The paper under discussion has some shortcomings in regard to mathematical formulationof the problem related to acoustics, its justification, some references analyses and the text, and we feelthat this study has not been finished to its full extent. From the point of view of acoustic jet formation,the mathematical model used by the authors has a number of significant limitations which are nottaken into account. Moreover, the formal analogy between the parameters of electromagnetic wavesand acoustic waves should be used with caution in the conditions of localized beams (acoustic jet),and the limits of their application should be justified.
DOI:10.3390/math10234502